Best Teams to Use in MLB The Show 25 – Power, Pitching, and Depth Rankings
MLB The Show 25 gives players more tools than ever to build their dream rosters or MLB The Show 25 Stubs compete online with powerhouse teams. Whether you’re grinding through Diamond Dynasty, tackling Franchise mode, or dominating Ranked Online, picking the right team can make a massive difference. With new roster updates, refined player ratings, and improved AI tendencies, some clubs clearly stand out for their balance of power, speed, and pitching.
Here’s a detailed breakdown of the best teams to use in MLB The Show 25, ranked by their offensive firepower, defensive reliability, and depth on the mound.
1. Atlanta Braves – The Complete Package
The Atlanta Braves continue to dominate MLB The Show 25 with one of the most balanced and powerful lineups in the league. Ronald Acuña Jr. remains a superstar threat at the plate and on the bases, offering elite contact, power, and fielding ratings. Matt Olson provides heavy left-handed pop, while Austin Riley continues to be one of the most reliable power hitters in the game.
The Braves’ pitching staff is equally impressive. Spencer Strider’s high strikeout ability and devastating slider make him a top-tier starter in-game, and Max Fried’s control and movement complement him perfectly. With Raisel Iglesias locking down the bullpen, the Braves are a force in both 9-inning and shorter online games.
Why choose them: Perfect balance between offense and pitching. They’re elite in Diamond Dynasty and online ranked matches due to their flexibility and raw power.
2. Los Angeles Dodgers – Depth and Star Power
The Dodgers remain one of the most consistent powerhouse teams in MLB The Show 25. Their lineup features elite contact hitters like Mookie Betts and Freddie Freeman, who dominate both lefties and righties. The addition of young prospects gives players more depth in Franchise mode, offering future stars with solid ratings right out of the gate.
Pitching is where the Dodgers truly shine. Walker Buehler and Tyler Glasnow lead a devastating rotation, while Brusdar Graterol and Evan Phillips give you multiple shutdown bullpen options.
Why choose them: Incredible roster depth and consistency make the Dodgers a perfect choice for players who want balance and reliability across every inning.
3. Texas Rangers – Offensive Firestorm
The reigning champions are built for power and momentum in MLB The Show 25. Corey Seager and Marcus Semien remain elite middle infielders, while Adolis García brings raw slugging power that translates into monstrous home run potential in-game. Josh Jung adds another dangerous bat in the lineup, and Jonah Heim provides defensive stability behind the plate.
On the pitching side, Nathan Eovaldi and Max Scherzer (if healthy) deliver veteran reliability, and young arms like Cody Bradford offer franchise players development potential.
Why choose them: Their offense can carry games even if your pitching slips. The Rangers are perfect for players who want explosive hitting and clutch late-game rallies.
4. New York Yankees – Home Run Heaven
For players who love hitting moonshots, the Yankees remain one of the most satisfying teams to use. Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton continue to tower over opposing pitchers, while Anthony Rizzo provides balance from the left side. The addition of Juan Soto in MLB The Show 25 only amplifies their already monstrous offense.
Pitching-wise, Gerrit Cole is one of the best aces in the game, capable of throwing high-velocity fastballs and filthy sliders. The bullpen, led by Clay Holmes, remains strong and can lock down the final innings in tight games.
Why choose them: Raw power and highlight-reel hitting. The Yankees are perfect for players who love going deep and want to end games with quick bursts of offense.
5. Baltimore Orioles – Young, Fast, and Dangerous
The Orioles are one of the most exciting young teams in MLB The Show 25, featuring elite prospects and rising stars. Gunnar Henderson and Adley Rutschman bring elite fielding and hitting tools, while Jackson Holliday’s addition adds future franchise value. Cedric Mullins provides speed and gap-hitting ability, making them versatile for both simulation and competitive play.
The pitching staff is young but talented. Grayson Rodriguez and Kyle Bradish offer developing aces with high potential and excellent movement ratings, making the Orioles a great long-term Franchise mode pick.
Why choose them: Ideal for players who enjoy building around young talent and developing a dynasty from the ground up.
6. Houston Astros – Veteran Dominance
Few teams offer the mix of experience, power, and pitching consistency that the Astros bring. Yordan Alvarez is one of the most dominant power hitters in MLB The Show 25, while José Altuve and Kyle Tucker round out a lethal top of the lineup.
Framber Valdez and Cristian Javier anchor one of the strongest rotations in the game, supported by a reliable bullpen led by Ryan Pressly.
Why choose them: The Astros are a veteran squad that rewards smart pitch selection and situational hitting. They’re great for both experienced and tactical players.
7. Philadelphia Phillies – Clutch Performers
The Phillies bring clutch hitting and postseason-ready energy into MLB The Show 25. Bryce Harper remains a fan favorite, while Kyle Schwarber and Trea Turner give the lineup balance between power and speed.
Aaron Nola and Zack Wheeler provide a dominant 1-2 punch on the mound, and José Alvarado offers a lethal left-handed bullpen option.
Why choose them: For players who thrive on late-inning comebacks and high-intensity matchups, the Phillies are a blast to use.
Final Thoughts
When choosing the best team in MLB The Show 25, the decision ultimately depends on your playstyle. Want to crush home runs? Go with the Yankees or Rangers. Prefer balance and control? Choose the Braves or Dodgers. Want to build a young, fast team for Franchise? The Orioles are your future dynasty.
Each of these teams offers a unique blend of power, pitching, and strategy — and buy MLB Stubs mastering their strengths is the key to dominating the diamond in MLB The Show 25.
MLB The Show 25 gives players more tools than ever to build their dream rosters or MLB The Show 25 Stubs compete online with powerhouse teams. Whether you’re grinding through Diamond Dynasty, tackling Franchise mode, or dominating Ranked Online, picking the right team can make a massive difference. With new roster updates, refined player ratings, and improved AI tendencies, some clubs clearly stand out for their balance of power, speed, and pitching.
Here’s a detailed breakdown of the best teams to use in MLB The Show 25, ranked by their offensive firepower, defensive reliability, and depth on the mound.
1. Atlanta Braves – The Complete Package
The Atlanta Braves continue to dominate MLB The Show 25 with one of the most balanced and powerful lineups in the league. Ronald Acuña Jr. remains a superstar threat at the plate and on the bases, offering elite contact, power, and fielding ratings. Matt Olson provides heavy left-handed pop, while Austin Riley continues to be one of the most reliable power hitters in the game.
The Braves’ pitching staff is equally impressive. Spencer Strider’s high strikeout ability and devastating slider make him a top-tier starter in-game, and Max Fried’s control and movement complement him perfectly. With Raisel Iglesias locking down the bullpen, the Braves are a force in both 9-inning and shorter online games.
Why choose them: Perfect balance between offense and pitching. They’re elite in Diamond Dynasty and online ranked matches due to their flexibility and raw power.
2. Los Angeles Dodgers – Depth and Star Power
The Dodgers remain one of the most consistent powerhouse teams in MLB The Show 25. Their lineup features elite contact hitters like Mookie Betts and Freddie Freeman, who dominate both lefties and righties. The addition of young prospects gives players more depth in Franchise mode, offering future stars with solid ratings right out of the gate.
Pitching is where the Dodgers truly shine. Walker Buehler and Tyler Glasnow lead a devastating rotation, while Brusdar Graterol and Evan Phillips give you multiple shutdown bullpen options.
Why choose them: Incredible roster depth and consistency make the Dodgers a perfect choice for players who want balance and reliability across every inning.
3. Texas Rangers – Offensive Firestorm
The reigning champions are built for power and momentum in MLB The Show 25. Corey Seager and Marcus Semien remain elite middle infielders, while Adolis García brings raw slugging power that translates into monstrous home run potential in-game. Josh Jung adds another dangerous bat in the lineup, and Jonah Heim provides defensive stability behind the plate.
On the pitching side, Nathan Eovaldi and Max Scherzer (if healthy) deliver veteran reliability, and young arms like Cody Bradford offer franchise players development potential.
Why choose them: Their offense can carry games even if your pitching slips. The Rangers are perfect for players who want explosive hitting and clutch late-game rallies.
4. New York Yankees – Home Run Heaven
For players who love hitting moonshots, the Yankees remain one of the most satisfying teams to use. Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton continue to tower over opposing pitchers, while Anthony Rizzo provides balance from the left side. The addition of Juan Soto in MLB The Show 25 only amplifies their already monstrous offense.
Pitching-wise, Gerrit Cole is one of the best aces in the game, capable of throwing high-velocity fastballs and filthy sliders. The bullpen, led by Clay Holmes, remains strong and can lock down the final innings in tight games.
Why choose them: Raw power and highlight-reel hitting. The Yankees are perfect for players who love going deep and want to end games with quick bursts of offense.
5. Baltimore Orioles – Young, Fast, and Dangerous
The Orioles are one of the most exciting young teams in MLB The Show 25, featuring elite prospects and rising stars. Gunnar Henderson and Adley Rutschman bring elite fielding and hitting tools, while Jackson Holliday’s addition adds future franchise value. Cedric Mullins provides speed and gap-hitting ability, making them versatile for both simulation and competitive play.
The pitching staff is young but talented. Grayson Rodriguez and Kyle Bradish offer developing aces with high potential and excellent movement ratings, making the Orioles a great long-term Franchise mode pick.
Why choose them: Ideal for players who enjoy building around young talent and developing a dynasty from the ground up.
6. Houston Astros – Veteran Dominance
Few teams offer the mix of experience, power, and pitching consistency that the Astros bring. Yordan Alvarez is one of the most dominant power hitters in MLB The Show 25, while José Altuve and Kyle Tucker round out a lethal top of the lineup.
Framber Valdez and Cristian Javier anchor one of the strongest rotations in the game, supported by a reliable bullpen led by Ryan Pressly.
Why choose them: The Astros are a veteran squad that rewards smart pitch selection and situational hitting. They’re great for both experienced and tactical players.
7. Philadelphia Phillies – Clutch Performers
The Phillies bring clutch hitting and postseason-ready energy into MLB The Show 25. Bryce Harper remains a fan favorite, while Kyle Schwarber and Trea Turner give the lineup balance between power and speed.
Aaron Nola and Zack Wheeler provide a dominant 1-2 punch on the mound, and José Alvarado offers a lethal left-handed bullpen option.
Why choose them: For players who thrive on late-inning comebacks and high-intensity matchups, the Phillies are a blast to use.
Final Thoughts
When choosing the best team in MLB The Show 25, the decision ultimately depends on your playstyle. Want to crush home runs? Go with the Yankees or Rangers. Prefer balance and control? Choose the Braves or Dodgers. Want to build a young, fast team for Franchise? The Orioles are your future dynasty.
Each of these teams offers a unique blend of power, pitching, and strategy — and buy MLB Stubs mastering their strengths is the key to dominating the diamond in MLB The Show 25.
